I have a big problem, guys.

I am a pretty damn militant Atheist who hates all religion, but it seems that most people that are attracted to me are Catholics. As in devout, practicing Catholics. I've dated 3 (only one put out), and I can name 4 women that have had crushes on me that were practicing Catholics. Right now, I have this girl that is really creeping me out with her pursuit towards me (to the point of it getting to be stalkerish) is a devout Catholic except in terms of sexuality. And that's not counting those who were simply raised Catholics...

Now, I really have no problem with dating a theist, but the amount of Catholics attracted to me, especially considering my strong views about their religion, is what puzzles me. What am I doing that attracts Catholics?!