I owe you a sincere apology. I mixed you with >>17, a narcissistic girl who wants nothing less than gorgeous guys. I see that your expectations are quite different. I for myself can say that girl's looks don't play an ultimate role when I decide to ask her out. There should be some physical attraction between the two, but that's very subjective (i.e., what I find attractive may be plain ugly to somebody else). So, guys are into girls' looks as far as they find them subjectively attractive. I guess it has to do with genes and pheromones. I would say that physical compatibility is a better term.
I noticed about myself that when I like the posture of a girl, her body language and expression, I ignore what I don't like (at first) about her. It may not work the same with all other guys, but I do think guys look for more in a girl than just facial or body features. In the end, that's why you'll meet a lot of handsome guys with below the average looking girls on the streets (and vice versa for that matter).
Again, I apologize for the mix-up