I do admit that I look more at good-looking guys than your average-looking one. But even then, I've managed to fall in love with a guy who is completely out of what I normally rate attractive people.
He's not Asian (my parents generally only approve of same-race people), he has facial hair, he has more than a little acne, he has braces, he's a gamer like me but likes first-person shooters more than RPGs, and I think he weighs about 190-220 lbs. But he's really nice, he's not ashamed to point out some flaw of mine and his lack of self-esteem is absolutely adorable.
Rant aside, it may seem like looks are very important but sometimes the weirdest things happen at the weirdest times.