I love her and I know she loves me but how do I convert that into a relationship? We broke up because this was both of our first relationships and we got a little scared of hurting each other.
Tell her that exactly.
Say "I'm scared of hurting you, but regardless... I really love you."
You have to talk to her. No matter what we say, you have to tell her or else nothing will be helped.
I read "we got a little scared" and immediately thought "bel-air".
What the fuck.
What if she says no?
Then she says no.
Unfortunately I have feelings, if she says no she might as well shit all over them. Is there any surefire way to get her to say yes, or even consider it?
Just checked my emails:
"U know I still love u, and I would luv it, but I just can't handle it right now. I have sooo much going on that I'm just exhausted. You deserve someone who can be fully and completly committed to you. That's what I want for you"