If you're a gaming/comic nerd, keep that to yourself when you talk to women ^_^
Well, first of all that internet relationship wasn't real. You were just plugged into the wall. Second, love at first sight isn't real at all. There's instant attraction and that's it. How can you fall in love with someone you don't even know? It doesn't make sense.
I don't really know what to say. I guess try not to let it consume you're life. A new girl usually enters my life when I least expect it to happen and when I'm not looking in her direction. That's how life is. Everything happens unexpectedly. But when that opportunity to make your move comes, you gotta MAKE IT right then and there. Don't wait and come to 4-ch to ask what you should do. You'll know.