I am the guy from post#315.

Ok, I have memorized the fretboard. NOW WHAT?

1) He doesn't teach you how to tune your guitar
2 He doesn't teach any chords, even the basic ones
3) He doesn't teach you any songs.

The guy promised that he would make make me memorize the fretboard and that's what he did. But he also indicated that I would be a good guitar player just on the basis of knowing the fretboard. Didn't happen.

So, you might say that it is a promise only half-fulfilled. I must say though that you won't be wasting your time with the lesson. You will have memorized the fretboard. Now that IS a significant step for beginners.

Therefore, my recommendation on the product: 50%. (100% if you get it for free, like I did, from Limewire).