Why do we limit ourselves to wizards from Harry Potter? There was Gandalf somewhere but was mentioned once or twice. What about Dave Duncan's "A man of his word" books? A wizard (I don't remember/know if this name was used as I didn't read english version) there could do anything and was as good as man can be in any field (which also includes physical abilities - strength, reflex and stuff).

So my word is that "A man of his word"'s wizards would kick both "Harry Potter"'s wizards and jedis. But it makes it too easy so it is better to forget about it and go back to Harry Potter vs Star Wars argument :P