>>1
The only negative thing I will say about the TV adaptation so far is that the second season ED is totally wrong for it, and that this has never been more clear than at the end of episode 16. "Torch" is a nice enough song, but it just doesn't fit the mood of After Story at all. I've seen several people suggest that they should have used it for the first season, and saved "Dango Daikazoku" for After Story, and I tend to agree. KyoAni have done such masterful work with the rest of the series (and with the other Key adaptations), that I am really surprised and, frankly, disappointed that they would do such a poor job on this one point.

>>3
IMO, the Key games are better off without the H-scenes. Key themselves admit that they don't contribute anything to the plot, and as such I find them disruptive. Call me crazy, but I don't think crying and fapping mix well.