>>2
OP here. The high school girl was like that, but this same love interest of mine seem to not have that problem, fortunately. She likes to talk more than me, and we set each other off in conversation on even the most mundane topics, but as we both enjoy each other's company so much it really doesn't matter what we talk about.

Our first date tonight went extremely well, I hope for more good ones like that in the future. We're at the point where we're dating, I make fun of her and she makes fun of me, yet not quite officially boyfriend and girlfriend yet, but from what I can tell and considering how well we get along, that could be the next step. What is most encouraging is that I know all of the guys who she has dated before, they all go to the same school, and from what she has described and from what I know about them, I believe I'm the most well rounded candidate. I'll let the time slide for now and continue along this path, but at some point I will pop the question as to whether we're "official" or not. Wish me luck.