There was a thread like this in /anime/ and, although it seems to have died from lack of interest, I liked it. Let's try it here.
For instance, assuming >>0's favorite is THE GAME: What fun is a game that can't be won? Also, you just lost it.
My favorite: Metal Gear Solid 3
No protracted arguments in this thread please, just keep it going.
MGS3 sucks because the low level soldiers become the patriots!??= MGS4 sucks too (storywise and BB back alive?!)
Shadow hearts 2
>>2's game sucks because nobody played it
Twisted tales of spike mcfang
>>3 That's my favorite game. Give it back.
2nd favorite game... Um... Wild Guns?
>>4 misspelled Wild Arms, which sucks.
Mendel Palace.
any of you fags up for some browser based shit?
>>6
DIE!
>>8
Blizzard should stick with fantasy games.
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
Blocky combat system is BLOCKY, it breaks the entire mood when fighting with it's turned based bullshit. I'm glad BioWare ironed that out in Mass Effect
Team Fortress 2
>>10 Slow as all fuck on my reasonably modern computer which can do HL2 at 200fps at decent resolutions.
Tsukihime
>>12
Nrvnsqr fucking Chaos.
Conquests of the Longbow: The Legend of Robin Hood
>>13
I've never even heard of this.
Totally Rad.
>>14
I've never even heard of this.
Megaten Nocturne
Never heard of it, but it's faggy.
Imperishable Night
Too easy.
Battletoads
Too hard.
La-Mulana
Too gay.
Earthbound
Dragon Quest clone set in America
Gunstar Heroes
>>20 Didn't get enough recognition even though it didn't suck, thus it sucks though since it wasn't recognized enough.
Monster Hunter
Based solely on learning attack patterns. Nobody beat their first Kut-Ku and you fucking know it. Also, is too addictive a valid complaint?
Gitaroo Man
they didn't make enough of them
ogre battle
uncontrollable battles, abhorrently lengthy and difficult customization, secret plots and stories uncovered only through exploration of utterly pointless and out-of-the-way terrain.
Xenogears
>>24 HURR DURR HOW I MAKE PLOTLINE COHERENT?
Chrono Trigger
Programmer: Yeah, Jim and I were trying, but there's no way to fix the emulated timing issues with Chrono Trigger, or FF6...
BOSS: OH WELL, chuck it out anyway.
Programmer: you got it, boss.
Silent Protagonist is Silent
Also, not enough innuendo.
Also, some of the main characters are HORRIBLY KILLED in the sequel!
(it was hard to think of bad things about Chrono trigger)
Star Ocean 2
i never played it, but i heard the voice acting is terrible.
Super Mario Bros.3
Mario with a racoon tail. Need I say more?
Fallout 2.